Southern Baptists, sexual abuse and a culture in crisis


The country’s largest Protestant denomination has been embroiled in a battle royal for several years. At last, it has decided to make public the names of clergy and personnel who have been accused of sexually abusing youth. Ministers at the highest level of the denomination, equivalent to Catholic cardinals and bishops, are expected to be on the list.

Southern Baptists comprise the second largest Christian communion in the United States, only behind Catholics in the number of people attending their churches. They are significantly influential in all sectors. Many Baptists serve in Congress, among them prominent U.S. senators, including Lindsey Graham, (R.-South Carolina) and Ted Cruz, (R.-Texas). Two living former presidents, Jimmy Carter and Bill Clinton, are from the Baptist tradition.

Southern Baptists operate 57 colleges and universities, many secondary and elementary schools, and a network of major hospitals, coast to coast, serving, and hiring, thousands upon thousands upon thousands of Americans.

Important for Baptists are foreign missions. A major focus is historically Catholic South America. A Brazilian bishop, whose diocese is in the orbit of the great city of Sao Paulo, Brazil, told this columnist that half of the people listed in his parishes only a decade ago are Southern Baptists today. Many Hispanic Americans are joining Baptist congregations.

So, news of Southern Baptists is news.

Some observers of American religion think that the Baptist list will match, or exceed, in breadth and cover-up what has angered and humiliated Catholics for a generation.

(As an aside, not infrequently heard, in and out of Catholic circles, is that aggravating the problem in the Catholic Church has been priestly celibacy and too much same-gender sexual attraction among priests. Well, 99% of the accused Southern Baptist perpetrators are men married to women, and almost all are fathers.)

Because of long, determined and still evident resistance within the denomination to addressing cases of abuse publicly, and assertively, much work will be needed to repair what has occurred and to develop policies to prevent future cases. Since the Baptist disgraces, in too many American minds, religion itself, and religious values, Catholics should wish well Baptist efforts to find remedies.

Overall, the bright light piercing the dark clouds is that, everywhere, authorities, and rank and file, want action. Finally, finally, physicians define pedophilia as gravely injuring victims. Legislators are enacting laws. Police are responding. If Catholics take satisfaction in anything, it should be in the fact that Catholic leaders, popes on down, have moved to right the wrongs.

The problem is not Catholic, Baptist or even religious. For example, the story and scope of abuse in the Boy Scouts of America is heartbreaking. So are the figures for public schools, to say nothing of incest and unreported cases.

Something is wrong, badly wrong, across Western civilization, not just in these named groups, but in attitudes.

Overwhelming traditional Christian culture, whether it be the United States, Ireland, Australia, Spain, Canada, France or Chile, is the trend to yield to anything desired, repudiate all hesitation, regard personal gratification as everything, and judge sexuality simply as individual entertainment.

Sex exploitation of the vulnerable is one manifestation of a larger problem. People engage in physical intimacy, routinely, often rejecting commitment in marriage outright. Divorce is epidemic. So many cases involve infidelity. Lewdness fills everyday discourse and certainly the performing arts.

When did this process begin? Maybe it began 90 years ago with easy divorce, which Our Sunday Visitor’s founder, Archbishop John F. Noll, fought valiantly. Others say it started when, in the mid-1930s, major Protestant denominations accepted artificial contraception. Perhaps the Second World War, and adjustments in its aftermath, played a role, as have modern communications.

Whatever, Western culture is morally adrift. Witness the fury lately displayed when restrictions on abortion in this country were suggested. Moral standards mean little.

It is to be expected, the invariable result of forgetting Almighty God.

This article comes to you from Our Sunday Visitor courtesy of your parish or diocese.


Catholic News & Perspective

Provides information on the Church, the nation and the world from OSV, America's most popular and trusted national Catholic news source


Opening the Word: Christian peace differs from the worldview

Thursday, August 11, 2022
By: Father Joshua J. Whitfield A strange peace, undoubtedly. It’s a peace that’s disruptive. It’s strange because that’s... Read More

Imagine a world where states and women’s care centers worked together

Tuesday, August 9, 2022
By: Our Sunday Visitor Editorial Board For nearly 50 years, members of the pro-life movement found themselves trying to convince anyone and... Read More

The American Catholic problem today

Sunday, August 7, 2022
By: Msgr. Owen F. Campion Threats to the vitality of the Church in Europe 70 years ago, in large part prompting the Second Vatican Council, have... Read More

Opening the Word: A response of faith

Thursday, August 4, 2022
By: Catherine Cavadini This Sunday’s readings are all rooted in the story of Abraham. In Chapters 12-22 of Genesis, Abraham is presented as a... Read More

When God opens doors

Tuesday, August 2, 2022
By: Scott P. Richert When a door opens before you, do you walk through? I’m not talking about metaphorical doors, but actual physical doors.... Read More

Catholics rally in support of Michigan pro-life center after vandalism

Sunday, July 31, 2022
By: Karla Dorweiler When Mary Wilkerson drove past offensive signs in the front yard of a home in late June, she was angry. Not just because her... Read More

Opening the Word: Are we the rich fool?

Thursday, July 28, 2022
By: Father Joshua J. Whitfield Someone — we don’t know who — shouts to Jesus, “Teacher, tell my brother to share the... Read More

Longtime youth minister offers suggestions to get teens excited about Mass

Tuesday, July 26, 2022
By: Mark Hart My cradle Catholic parents instilled in me the importance of going to Mass religiously (no pun intended) but were never able to... Read More

Finding the sacred in the secular as a Catholic

Sunday, July 24, 2022
By: Ava Lalor Before we were even engaged, my fiancé and I already had a few details planned for our wedding Mass, including most of our... Read More

Opening the Word: Our daily bread

Thursday, July 21, 2022
By: Catherine Cavadini “Lord, teach us to pray…” This week the Gospel of Luke teaches us about prayer, echoing the Our Father as... Read More